I knocked off a star because the first one came with 3 deep gouges in the wood in the front where you would clearly see it. Customer service sent me another one, which had a few minor imperfections but not noticeable like the first one and since it is handmade, I didn't mind. It's a heavy, solid mirror. I love the natural variations and color of the wood. If you like authentic, organic materials and don't mind the subtle variations that may come with handmade, you'll love it. If you want sleek, smooth perfection, this might not be for you. I am using it above my walnut vanity in an updated bath that I would call tropical vintage, with dark green jungle/palm tree wallpaper, so for me it's perfect.