I love the Dovie Corner Bookcase! It's very pretty and is the perfect size for a small unused corner in my bedroom. I only gave it 4 stars because the 1st shipment arrived with missing pieces as well as some dings and the replacement also arrived with missing pieces, some dings and a bit of rust on the inside of a few of the pieces where they attach.  Fortunately, they were different missing pieces so we were able to put it together between the 2 shipments and I didn't have to use any of the pieces that had dings or rust. Overall I'm very happy with it!