I got this last year and it did hold up well during the winter so I was happy with that.  The issue I had with it was that the zipper door broke on one side the first time I used it.  Other than that, it's held up way better than I expected and was great for my ferns through the winter months.  I'd have given it a 5 star if the zipper had not broke immediately.  It was very easy to put together and didn't take long.