These cushions are thick and soft. The color is spot on (I got the light green ones) The cover material seems strong and durable, and they appear to be stitched together well.  So far there have been no problems. I haven’t had them for very long so I cannot speak to how long they will stay in good shape, but because of the exposure they will no doubt receive at my house (slight exposure to the elements, dogs, and the occasional feral cat looking for a place to sleep for the night) I’m not exactly expecting them to last a life time. If these cushions last 4-5 years, and I currently have no reason to think that they won’t,  I’ll be completely satisfied, especially given the price point which is excellent. 3 cushions for the price of what one cushion would typically cost, from what I could find elsewhere. 
5 stars for overall appearance and quality workmanship, and 4 stars because of the remaining mystery of overall durability over time.