I was searching for two matching mirrors for the master bath. I bought one to start to make sure we liked it. It showed up and was everything I wanted - cute, slightly rustic/weathered, but still all white and no cracks. So I decided to order the second one, and it showed up looking much different. This one took rustic to a whole new level with some cracking, yellowing paint, etc. Needless to say the two looked weird together and could not be placed in a bathroom side by side. I ended up having to buy some white chalk paint to paint both of them, and I'm hoping that they match enough to be side by side on the wall now. 

I'm giving it 3 stars, because I did love it when the first one showed up. But now I'm disappointed in the inconsistency & needing to spend extra money on paint.