We've had these chairs only 2 weeks and so far all is well.  Hubby says construction was not at all bad. Would like to review next season to see how they hold up.  We bought them on sale.  They are obviously not the very best quality in terms of thickness of wood,  lacking rounded arms and a rounded curve at the front of the chair,  and no curvature along the back. Having said all this,  they serve our needs perfectly, as they are still comfortable to sit in. We are happy with this purchase. Also, the red is as vibrant as shown in the pictures.