We've had this chair for over a year now and it still remains my husband's favorite reading chair.  Our little Havanese has deemed it the best chair in the house too as it is also her favorite.  I was concerned that the arms would get dirty from elbows and forearms but it has held up well so far.  Very pleased with the chair.  I gave it 4 stars because it could be a few inches higher to be the best seating height.  

Pros: Easy Assembly
Cons: Chair height