We have been looking for a bronze or black metal barn light for our cabin for quite some time. My main criteria were 1-not too big and 2-not too fancy. My husband liked this one since the base is rectangular since he will have to cut the siding out to mount it and square will make it easier. The quality is great. The finish is to look worn with bits of bronze/copper colored metal showing at the edges and in bits throughout. It arrived expertly packed completely embedded in styrofoam. The only reason for 4 stars is I haven't mounted it on the cabin yet but I think it will be great.