The shelf heights were not optimal for the intended uses...BUT even using just 3 shelves, the unit is great. I did not plan to put very heavy items on it, so using it to organize dog food, recycling, and laundry supplies was ideal. I really liked the 23 1/2 in width as it fits perfectly in the small space in my mud room. Assembly was easy, the shelf is sturdy, and sits stably even with the load. I didn't note any defects in the finish. Aside from wishing the shelf height was adjustable, the only issue was that there was sufficient damage to the package that it is possible that the one missing screw was lost through one of the small open areas (or wasn't included?) Impossible to know. But no worries since I only used 3 shelves. This is a good unit for small spaces and not extremely heavy loads.