Physically this fit our needs and some of the unique design bits are appealing, the extra-large main door for general access and the vari-temp drawer. I like the icemaker setup as it doesn't waste a lot of fridge space like most thru-the door units. However, the fridge has displayed an annoying defect - it periodically(randomly) sets a hi-temp freezer alarm - real in that the temp is elevated - but if left alone, it gets back to the set temp (Doors are properly closed all the time. This seems to be happening more frequently though and the factory warranty(1 yr) just expired. The ice-maker quit working after a month or so but after a month or two of silence it resumed operation and has been flawless since.