Overall this is a great product. I would give 3.75 on 5
POSITIVES:
I love how well it is built and how sturdy it is. I would highly recommend it to anyone who wants to keep the entrance to their home visibly shoe-free. 
The deign is good and the cushion provided is of high quality.
Love the little storage space on top. My dog's leash, umbrellas and my hat can now all be one place.

NEGATIVES
* 2 sets of holes for the doors were misaligned and needed custom drilling. 0.5 off for this
* The instructions are okay. I wish they had given a magnifying glass to make sense of what is written or made the instructions as 5 or 6 pages.. Everything on a single sheet of paper is ridiculous 0.5 off for this
* If you have feet size beyond 10.5, you cannot fit 8 pairs in it. I have size 12 feet and my shoes have to go sideways. Does the job and between the garage and the entrance, I can get my shoes organized, but this is sort of inconvenience. 0.25 off for that