We've been looking for counter stools for sometime and were very interested when seeing these online. They looked good in the photo but at such a reasonable price point were reluctant. After reading the reviews, we ordered them knowing they could be returned.  They are well made, sturdy, look good and the seat is actually a little larger than the stools they are replacing. We're very happy with the purchase.  

Pros: Great value, fully assembled, sturdy, look good
Cons: need felt pads, but this is a minor point