These towel bars are terrific so far. I was looking for something to replace the single towel bar I had in the cupboard under my kitchen sink. That one’s padding had deteriorated over the years enough that the towel’s hangers had become loose on the cupboard door. Every time the towel was used, and the towel apparatus pulled up on, the whole thing rattled around terribly on that cupboard door, marring the door’s finish and moving the location of the towel bar. What an annoyance! 

But this two-pack of towel bars is terrific. The over-the-door hooks are nicely padded and are snug enough that they stay where I put them. I am happy with the black finish, which disappears against my very dark espresso cabinetry. 

Bottom line: I am super happy with these towel bars!