I followed the directions carefully, making sure part A and part B were in the correct position (instructions say it will not line up if not in the proper placement). I had 1 slat that was practically impossible to align correctly to get the screw inserted and tightened. It was approximately 2 millimeters off. Very frustrating. That alone made me give the lower review. I would have returned it if I could. I think the finish is ok at best. It isn't smooth and looks almost like something would if it had been refinished. Overall, it appears to be sturdy and will be a nice addition to my garden. For the price, I wasn't expecting much and unfortunately it has lived up to my expectation. What I like about it is it is heavy and can easily sit 2 adults. I was concerned about lighter versions being blown over in wind storms.