This paper holder (matte black) is well made, sleek and modern looking. Very sturdy metal. It has enough room for larger toilet rolls, we have found. The curved roll bar end seems sufficient to keep the roll from slipping off, as we have had no trouble with this. We decided to install it on the left side wall which also helps to keep the roll in place as you pull to remove a piece of paper, because you are tugging towards the closed end. The lip on the top tray is handy to keep items in place. Overall excellent! We’ve since ordered two more in chrome for the other busy bathrooms in the house.