I bought this for a trip to Yellowstone, and even though we're not camping, we'll be cooking all of our meals.  I debated a grill vs griddle, and the griddle seemed easier since I can cook everything on it (rather than a grill with a separate griddle piece).  I've used it multiple times at home to be sure I know how it cooks, and so far I really like it.  It's really easy to get used to, especially if you're accustomed to cast iron pans at home.  I got the lid as well, which I think is good to have, but it does add a bit of bulk so I'm not sure whether I'll be bringing it this time.  I gave it 4 stars because I'd like it to get just a bit hotter.  I tried to really sear some burgers but by the time they had really good color on both sides, they were medium well.