This one is hard to rate. It was ordered for a client, and although my guys put it together, there was some issue with the way one of the doors closed (or didn't close). I had to end up eating the cost, but it's fine, I just added it to my staging inventory. Heavy to move and to me the door issue is forgivable. But the customer is always right, right? I'd give it a 5 for style and a 4 for craftsmanship.