We returned our first order from Wayfair and then purchased this Penny Tile in Truffle.  We are SO PLEASED with the color and tile.  So easy to install (we took our time). It truly is a classic cream/tan that goes with anything.  Our house was built in 2005 with the standard oak kitchen cabinets so we wanted to make sure we didn't get a backsplash that was too "gold".  We ordered 10% overage too and had way more left over than we thought - so now we will use it in the half bath :)