I cannot judge much on the carpet my ratings is based off the return policy & non existing "exchange" process they DON'T have. 
I am returned unopened but it was just way too shaggy & fluffy for my dining area (I can tell by seeing & feeling the carpet from the open areas of the packaging). 
It was my fault for ordering a size too big so I had to lose $26 to return it. I've spent a lot of money at Wayfair but from now on I will make Wayfair a last resort when ordering anything.