We love it! - This version is really the size of a garage door and makes a great visual impact even on our beige color door. So easy to put up and it stays on well even thru weather changes.
You do need to place the pieces so they don’t hit a seam in the door if you plan to open your garage - gut placement works even on a door that is not completely flat.
My grandkids love it and ask mom and dad to drive past often. 
The carrot is very realistic and the coal an even matte black.
So much easier than putting up lights and lets our house be a little different than the rest of the block.