Purchased my first set of this from Macy's.  When I saw it a year later on wayfair site for a better price I jump at the chance to add to my set.   I read lots reviews on other sites before I purchased thie first set.  The reviews noted that the knife often slips off edge of the plate.  That is true.  But I loved the look of the knife as well as the rest is the set.  It is a simple  elegant design that one will never get tire of.  The weight of the utensils is perfect.  The finish wears well from frequent dishwasher Washington and general family abuse.   I like the wider straight edge of the handle bases.  That keeps the silverware from sliding down in in dishwasher rack.