Love these - I think they're fantastic - exactly what I was looking for.  I selected them largely based off of other reviews.  They are big and chunky, but in my opinion they give a great, different look to the kitchen.  We had stock knobs in the past, so these are taking a little getting used to, but they're wonderful.  The reason I took off one star is because even though we got the black finish, it is definitely a powder coat.  At least 1-2 per 10 had some kind of scuff, scratch or dent - likely due to shipping rattling.  I ordered 30 because we needed 27 and at least 3 were deeply scratched beyond use, so it was a good thing we over ordered.  So just beware of this and maybe don't let your kids take hammers or chisels to your knobs.