I gave the chairs two stars simply because they came together and had all the pieces. Otherwise not very pleased. One of the chairs had a black smudge, most of which came off. One chair wobbles (has to remove one of the floor protectors to even it out). Two chair legs have very noticeable scratches, one which may actually be a split in the wood. No one would mistake these chairs for brand new. Only consolation is that I got them on sale.