There is a lot to like about these stools.  Sturdy, simple, rustic yet modern.  They seem to be reasonably well built.  We ordered 6 and there wasn't too much variation in the wood stain, but just enough to notice.  There is a small plastic "pad" on the bottom of the legs, but it is not soft.  We really like the 12" depth so they can be tucked in under the counter cleanly when they aren't being used...and the 24" width gives plenty of room to sit.