I ordered shorter 6 and 12 inch pulls of same satin gold finish but the shorter pull came up shining gold. Contacted Wayfair and they apologized for the defected items and the replacement pulls are on the way. Love Wayfair of its service and the pulls so much ended up changing my mind and ordering more pulls (hence missing hardwares on upper cabinets) My husband questioned my taste when I told him about the gold hardware now he's in love with the kitchen.