I ordered two. My only real criticism is that it was smaller than I expected. The black finish on it is flawless. The mounting plate is meant for a round electrical box. Mine was a rectangular box so it didn't fit but I obtained another plate and made it work. You can judge for yourself from the photo to see if it is too small. Four stars because the mounting plate should have been able to work with a rectangular plate. After a year with them, I'm more disappointed with their size. I should have returned them for larger ones. They do dress up the from entrance, with their elegant look. I did find that the factory assembly was slipshod. Some screws were very loose and it could have easily fallen apart. I advise anyone buying these to snug up, not tighten, all mounting screws before mounting.