I'd give it 4.5 stars if possible based on the fact one of the holes wasn't drilled out completely and I had to get a bit creative (not really a big deal), also the laminant edging on one of the pieces is a bit loose but hopefully none of the kids picks up on it (no pun intended on the "picking" because they will probably peel it if they find it).  Otherwise, it truly looks great and holds the 110 DVD's that we've managed to collect over the years with no problem. Very easy to put togther and looks great  in the room.