I'm pleased with appearance, but I'm struggling with the quality a bit.  One nightstand is perfect - it's light in appearance, but doesn't feel junky.  The other nightstand we ordered came with a paint defect on the top, which Joss and Main immediately offered to replace. However, the replacement came today and it too has both a paint defect on a corner AND the drawer doesn't open smoothly.  That's 2 for 3.  I would like to give this nightstand 5 stars because it is exactly what we were looking for and compared to other brands, it is more affordable - but I can't give it 5 stars because these defects are problematic.