Considering the "sale" price, I'll give it 3 stars, but at the "original" price, I have to give a 1 star. The metal base is actually pretty nice. The bottom cushion is an appropriate amount of firmness (any more cushy, and I think it'd deform and not look as nice).  The problem is that the arm rest does not have padding over the corner.  This does two things: 1, it makes it uncomfortable. 2, it rubs the underlying material (cheap wood?) against the fabric, causing it to split. 1 of 4 I purchased came split already, and I'm fully expecting the others to do the same over the next few months.

It really is a sign of cutting corners and doing the least amount of labor possible. I guess that's fine, but they shouldn't try to position this as a $1,000 chair on sale (very misleading). No, this is a $200 chair that you shouldn't expect to last very long.