Had this for a few weeks now and our dog seems to be fine with it as a nighttime bed in her crate. Not sure that she loves it but she hasn’t complained. The foam is thick and fairly firm and the cover is sturdy and washes very well. Our dog is 15lbs. And she doesn’t seem to sink into the foam, so maybe a bit firm, but I’m sure it will soften over time.
Sizing was perfect , no issues with foam smell, and shipped fairly fast.