Overall, it does its job well and is a good value for what we paid for it (we did get it on sale over Memorial Day weekend). Was easy to assemble. The lid doesn't fit properly, but we don't really use it in the first place. I do wish the poker was longer; I'll need to shop for a better one.

We've only had one fire in it so far, but it worked well. Right now I am thinking of keeping it in our shed between uses to stop it from getting wet and rusting out (it's fairly light, which makes it easier to transport). I do wish there was some kind of hole/drain in the bottom - we spray down the fire when we're done to stop it from flaring back up, and there's nowhere for the water to go currently.