We're giving it 2 stars because Wayfair is sending a replacement at no charge - otherwise it would be only one. First off, we received one that the top was so dented it couldn't be used for the purpose we wanted. That one looked like the advertised photos, but the second one we received was like pressed cardboard, painted completely different, and the entire top part came off from the base and nails were sticking out every which way. Wayfair has great customer service, but these products don't seem to have much consistency and I'm not sure we'd be surprised if the next set were damaged as well.