The broom cabinet is sturdy and was easy to assemble which is the only reason I gave it 2 stars instead of 1.  The finish on the cabinet is awful.  While this is just a broom cabinet, and not part of my dining room, I would have expected better.  I have had a number of furniture items over the years that need assembly, and there is typically thin foam sheets between the pieces to protect the surface. There was nothing (not even paper) between the panels, which caused a lot of scratches on all sides.  I was able to polish some of the scratches so that they aren't as noticeable.  However, the damage to the door is very noticeable and was not caused from poor packing or shipping.  The surface of the door panel has marks from top to bottom.  The damage is completely through the top layer and looks like it could be tire tracks.  Would NOT recommend this cabinet - at least not in black.  Maybe the scratches that happens from their poor packaging wouldn't be as noticeable on a white cabinet.