We like the way it looks, great plant holder.  However, there was not enough of the mulch like material so we had to stretch it some so dirt wouldn't fall through the bottom.  Also, there were no instructions on putting it together.  Finally, the design is pretty poor in the sense that the 6 pieces that come with it to lock it onto the rail are not intuitive.  There are 3 L pieces that have specific screw holes and 3 L pieces that just have a rectangular opening where you can put the screws wherever you want.  The two different types are not the same size and shape so it makes it kind of difficult - we had to rig it a bit.