This light, along with the matching pendant light to go over the breakfast nook table, is beautiful. The clean lines go really well with our new shaker-style cabinets, and it casts a LOT of bright light so the dark wood finishes don't seem so imposing. There is a dime-sized spot of rust on the outer rim. It wasn't offensive enough to bother sending the light back, but I had to dock a star. We just tried to position the light so you wouldn't see the spot from primary traffic areas.