I would actually rate this 4.5 stars out of 5 if it were an option.  Here is what I like and dislike about this dresser.  Likes: All natural wood construction, easy to assemble, very sturdy when built and very nice looking dresser when fully assembled.  Dislikes: This is pine wood so it is very soft.  We purchased three of these and each one has a blemish of some sort and those happened either during the assembly or just after the dresser was placed in its new home in our master closet.  For the price I believe that anyone would be very pleased with this dresser.  Summary: I am sure that this will be a nice piece of furniture for years to come based on the thoughtful design and quality of the wood/components.