A mixed review:  On the positive side, the shelves are attractive and look exactly like they did on the web site.  And, despite what some others said, I found the instructions worked very well for me.  On the less than positive side I must point out that after assembling 2 shelves I had the pointy ends of 2 screws on each shelf break through the shelf and damage each one in 2 places.  I attached pictures illustrating this.  In my opinion the screws are either too long, or the pre-drilled screw holes are drilled incorrectly.  So, in my opinion, despite the fact that the shelves were what Wayfair said they were, the damage that resulted from my careful assembly leads me to recommend not buying these.  I have 2 brand new shelves that were damaged during assembly.