So, I bought three for the front of my home. Two of the smaller for either side of the garage, and one for the front door. First and foremost, they are beautiful! Especially with Edisson bulbs. However, my rating of a three is for the shipping and apparent lack of thought on the manufacturers side. The two smaller ones (bought open box ironically) came in just fine. The third and larger unit came with all the glass shattered. Called Wayfair, customer service was great and they expedited a replacement; which...came with all the glass shattered. So rather than mess with it, I took a trip to Lowe’s, had glass cut, and I was in business. 

The wiring design is a bit of a miss. The wire that terminates to the electrical comes out below where it actually mounts. So you have to either modify your box or find a way to not pinch the wires when mounting. 

All in all, I am happy with my purchase, just not that I had to ultimately fix the design and glass issues on my own.