This 9' x 12 ' rug was better than I was anticipating it to be. Yes, it is thin as described, but I wasn't concerned with that since I was putting it over carpet. The colors are perfect with a nice creamy base color (some pictures depicted it to be more of a beige color, but it is definitely a nice light cream). One edge was curled up from the rolling process and I suspect it will fall and lay flat eventually; no big deal for me, since it is hidden by furniture. For me, this was a great buy for the money!