Ordered two lights and they are beautiful!  One is slightly lighter but I assume that is to be expected, not a big deal.  One light did have a black paint or pen mark on it but it appears the seller is replacing at no cost.  I will keep you posted... hope to change to a 5 star review! So far, I would totally buy these lights again.
UPDATE  just received my replacement light.  Happy to five a 5 star review!