I really wanted an upholstered white fabric headboard--but felt that would be far too difficult to keep clean.  I was a little worried about going with the vinyl in terms of appearance.  But I'm very pleased with the decision as it was more  affordable and as it turns out it looks spectacular.  The headboard is a gorgeous true white and adds a lot of class to our room.  The cons: With only four screws it is wobbly even at the low setting against the bed.  So we are going to have to figure out a way to make it more stable (add additional screws or something).  Also, the view of the black exposed metal railing on the side may be a problem depending on how your bed is situated in the room.  In our case you do see the side of the bed as you enter.  However a strategically placed end table should minimize this view.