About 60% of the 13 knobs we recieved had damange. The black matte finish seemed to be have damaged during production as the bags for each was intact. We debated sending them back, but being in Canada, and the product coming from the US, we didn't want a big wait. Makes them have a rustic look. Overall happy with the sizing and look. Since they are matte, they do show grease/oil so something to keep in mind.