Im giving three stars. After reading EVERY single review, I had much higher hopes. One star is for the style, one star for the price, one star for Wayfairs great customer service. I believe there was maybe one review that mentioned damages. I received 4 boxes, and every box appeared to have been open box merchandise - as they were worn and torn, ripped, and squished. Its no surprise that every box had damages - mostly cracks but some tiles were actually broken. Overall, I had 9 sheets with damages. I know reviews mentioned well packaged, but I didnt experience that at all. They really are beautiful, and I wish I had a better tile experience- especially since I have many more projects involving tiles. If you order samples, they are a representation of the tile but not how they will be shipped. The Customer Service team was great and sent me a replacement box. However, based on my experience, I think its too risky.