I got four of these chairs in the natural/brown finish. They’re well constructed, the fabric is seems quite durable and is a good, neutral match for most any setting. The natural caning is nice, as well. The wood color itself, however, is much more yellow than it appears in the picture. It would be a good match for golden oak or perhaps an oil-finished maple; however, they do not particularly go with anything that pulls brown. The undertones just make the whole chair read yellow. If that works with your other wood finishes and palette, go for it! If you have something with more browns and natural wood finishes, go for the black. They are a good value for the money and solidly put together, though.