I was sent 3 defective plates out of the 4.  One plate had  2 chips on the edge. One plate was totaly pitted on top. One plate has a white discoloration on the edge.  WayFair did make good on the defective plates and the replacements arrived in 2 days.  The plates are nice plates and I am happy with them after the replacement.  I am sorry to say, I am very learey now of ordering anything again as it may not end up so well.