Well made heavy duty,  thought it would improve efficiency of my Classic #1.  Definitely would make clean out easier.  I haven’t used it yet for 4 reasons.  One is reported increased charcoal consumption.  Two a lot of smaller  charcoal pieces that are still productive will end up in the clean out tray (maybe the reason for increased consumption).  Three, it works really well with the disc that comes in it.  Four I prefer the fit of the original ash floor plate better.  I doubt I will ever use it, but you never know.