Shape/style - 5 stars.
Comfort - 3.5 stars, really wish it was deeper, wider. Cushions are much harder than soft.
Quality - 3 stars. The back cushions come sewn to the couch which is not ideal in my preference. Also, one of them cam with the zipper sewn over so that it could not be completely closed and was therefore defluffing constantly. Also, you can feel the frame down the sides of the couch and it is very hard. The fabric on the sides is one punch/knock away from putting a hole in it due to lack of cushioning between the frame and fabric.