Finished product is 4 stars. Came with a few minor scratches on the legs but nothing noticeable once around table. Otherwise perfect and sturdy. I bought 4 chairs and assembly ranged from 1 star to 4. The first one I opened was chaoticly wrapped in enough tape and plastic to ship the delivery van it came in. After finally freeing all the parts, I discovered it came with the wrong sized Allen wrench. Totally useless. Fortunately, the other 3 chairs came with the right size wrench and were not mummified in tape, so all  fine in the end.