The 4 star is to catch your attention about the difficulty I had assembling this chair. The screw holes didn't line up but I ordered a replacement and it went together easy and I LOVE this chair. It is the perfect comfort for a dining chair (I believe they should be firm so over time they get soft but not too soft). The back seems like it would make you lean to far back but it's perfect. The color is also just as pictured and it is beautiful. It goes great with my modern farmhouse table! My cat decided it is her chair. 5 stars overall.