Although we have only had this appliance for a short period, we love it.  With the door in door and swing out basket we have easy access to the quick items.  The ice maker is more than adequate for our needs, as I have read some reviews that indicate the ice maker to be inadequate (we are not a large family).  The bottom freezer works perfectly, although a little hard to pull out due to the really good seal; but, we can live with that!  Smug free stainless steal, it really works.  I would recommend this product.