3.5 stars.  This box arrived on time, and it was heavy!  It looks beautiful!  The stainless steel top isn't the highest quality, but I plan on using the piece as a catch-all, so it's going to get scratched!  We had one major issue with a drawer.  It wasn't square, resulting in it not closing, or closing after jamming it closed...with a thunk.  (The side glide was being pulled out of the track.). We inserted a shim between the drawer front and side piece to make it slide smoothly.  The bottom of the drawer is big enough that the "extra width" at the front of the drawer is still okay.  (No gaps for things to fall out of the drawer.). The shim is not visible from the front, just looks a little weird when the drawer is opened.   Also, the casters are not connected....just slide into the bottom of the island.  I'd prefer that they atleast clicked into place.  (It was a challenge getting it upright, with all wheels in place.)