I give it 5 stars because it was what we needed—a small, comfortable recliner for a small space.  Downsides for other buyers: seat is narrow. Not sure my size 24 friend’s tush will fit...seriously.  Also, when it reclines, your body rises above the arms somewhat, so you’re not held in by the sides...it feels right ergonomically, but it’s not a chair to snuggle into.