I purchased this shower curtain for a new bathroom.  When I put it up there was a permanent mark of color that stood out on the white part of the curtain.  It was at the top and quite noticeable.  We called Wayfair and to my surprise they sent me another one right away and I did not have to  return the first one I received.  The second one was perfect without a blemish.  It looks great and I am happy it is the perfect length and it doesn't touch the shower floor.  I am pleased with the curtain and the service by Wayfair.  Thank you!