This candle is a favorite for some in my home. It has a strong throw. It is sweet, deep, and rich and you do get some vanilla every now and then. Very lovely, but I agree-it does not smell  like pumpkin or banana. I did buy a second one to alternate with Apple Pumpkin and Autumn Wreath (which is the perfect collection of fall scents). If you want banana, then go with Banana Bread. 
If you are looking for something baking in the oven, then Apple Pumpkin smells like a baked good baking (similar to banana bread without the banana).