I have had my flatware for a little about 2 weeks now and it is holding up great still! A lot of reviews I read for black flatware said that they would tarnish quickly, even after 1-2 washes. I have put mine in the dishwasher and hand washed and no tarnish spots so far. My only complaint is the water spots are very noticeable, but that can be expected. If they are dried the spots come right off, or you can even wipe it off with your finger. Otherwise I love the look and they feel good in your hand!