More like 3.5 stars.  Certainly not as durable as true Polywood - it’s much softer material and will scratch easily. When assembling make certain you put everything on a soft surface or will scratch it.   Also seat depth is not as deep as polywood chairs but then again might be perfect for you.  Overall you get what you pay for.  They are nice looking I’m just not crazy about quality. One more thing - assemble them near where you are placing them - moving them is a 3 person job unless you don’t care about affecting integrity of structure.  Now having to select my umbrella that will fit whereupon crank shaft isn’t positioned too low or umbrella can’t sit on ground