4 stars because there is a manufacturer defect. Otherwise this piece is lovely. The lip/skirt at the bottom was unfinished on the front. It is the same color, so it can still be used, but it is unfortunately noticeable. 
The seller was only accommodating when I demanded an even exchange. They wanted to give me a 15% discount or a refund for a return. The price had increased since I got it on sale, so that was not ideal. Once I demanded 60% discount or an even exchange they agreed to a 60% discount.