I have a queen pillow top mattress on top of a 4-drawer mattress box that sits on rails.  The bed's a little high so I opted for the king size bedspread.  It hangs over about 2 inches more than I'd like on each side after it's first washing, but I'm ok with that.  I don't think I'd be happy with the queen size because that'd come a full 8 inches shorter, which I didn't want because I don't want a dust ruffle.  If it bugs me enough and doesn't shrink a little more in the wash, it'll be easy enough the flip around and hem along the stitching of the binding without detracting from the look.  It's a good weight, the colors are true to the picture, and it fits just fine in front-loading machines for washdry. Even though I'll have to alter it a little bit to get it perfect, the price and quality merit a 5.  It's not the product's fault that I have the bedboxspring combo that's hard to fit. :