Everything I wanted in a paper towel holder, tears perfect every single time.  The base is heavy so there's no moving around when you want to tear a towel off.  It works with both select-a-size towels and regular.  I've torn them off with one hand and it never disappoints.  Sounds crazy to care so much about a paper towel holder, but I don't buy the really expensive brands of paper towels so it means a lot not to tear them to shreds.  This one also accommodates the jumbo size rolls.  Worth the extra money.  Also, the brushed stainless steel is a plus since it matches all my appliances.