I’d give this 5 stars as it is exactly what I wanted, looks & works great. The smell is the reason that I gave it 3 stars. We set it on the balcony for a week to air it out but the odor is still there. I can’t decide if it’s the glue holding the fabric in place or the fabric itself. We don’t smell it when the door is open but when it is, it’s alwful! It doesn’t absorb into my jewelry though.