One of the seats was missing the holes in the leather (I made holes with scissors) where the screws go and there were a few dings in the legs of the chair, but not noticeable from afar.  The seat is deeper than I imagined it, but overall I’m happy with the look of the chairs so I’m keeping them.  Not sure how the faux leather will hold up over time, but I hope now that my kids are grown it won’t be an issue.