I was torn between a 3 or 4 star. These are very cute shelves and I love the look. There were multiple imperfections though which are pictured. Scratches and dripping paint which I can never unsee. I was highly disappointed with what they give to hide the hardware. They give you white stickers also pictured. I’m used to receiving the plastic caps. Also they don’t give you enough for those on the inside of the shelf that you can see. This cheapens the look to anyone who knows they are there it finds them. The finish is very smooth which I do like. They are sturdy. The directions also could be improved. They only give you the very basics to put it together when they should be clearer as to which is the back vs the front.