I do not like any shower curtain liner and feel by now industry should have manages to make shower curtains that do not need liners.  I had a shower curtain once that did not require a liner.  Yes the curtain got wet, but it was already on a hanger.  The color liner I chose was Canary Yellow.  It is a pretty color.  The lady at Wayfair helped me find it..  The plastic on the shower curtain is thick and well made.  I just do not like shower curtain liners as I do not like plastic touching my body while I shower.  

Pros: Pros: Good Liner Quality and choice of color!  Easy to put up!
Cons: It is made of plastic.  It should be made of mylon or silk!