I am pleased overall with this mantle.  I would have given it 5 stars if the following didn't happen:  Arrived with small chip on front of mantle.  It's a heavy item so I didn't want to deal with a return.  To remedy the chip, I hung the mantle upside down and the chip isn't visible now.  Also, on one side of the mantle, the finish doesn't match.  It's dull and white - must have been a quality control issue on mine.  Thankfully the side that doesn't match isn't easily visible.  I like the look of the piece and everyone who sees it compliments it.