Got this for my 1 1/2 year old.  He loves to ride in it.  I liked that it could be converted to a bench sturdy enough for me to sit on.  A door would be nice as it is a little difficult for him to climb in but that probably wouldn't work with the design to convert to a bench.  I would rather have the bench because when he gets bigger he won't have a problem getting in.  Havn't tried the umbrella yet.  It's a great feature but with one pole I am sure it will spin in the wind.  Can't help but think there should be a way to have two posts.  Overall it's a great wagon and I get many compliments.  Would love rubber tires, but these are ok.