I really like the shape, the wide mouth and the relative ease of filling.  The glass is clear and lovely.  

The reasons for my reduced rating are that the dimensions were misleading, as the widest part of the shade is actually 15 inches, so the whole lamp is bigger than I expected based on the dimensions listed.  Also, the lamp I received DOES have a 3-way switch although two different Wayfair replies to questions stated that it does not.  Finally, the shade is a darker tan than it appears in the photos, and it would look better with a lighter shade.