Bought this with 0 reviews, and I'm so happy I did! If you're looking for a rustic mantle, I know all the ones you are looking at on Wayfair, and this one is the best! I'm so glad I didn't go with the "distressed" one with the corny hashmark distress marks. The "rough hewn" is the way to go--it's about texture and not those dark stabby-marks. This one is rustic and smooth at the same time... like rustic minimalism. Not as shiny as the photos, which I am happy with. Probably going to buy another for the other fireplace.