These are lovely solid plates, These ones didn't arrive as soon as the other ones which I'd ordered in blue.  The blue ones were much cheaper as was from packaging that had already been opened.  These red ones had 1 x plate which was chipped.  Wayfair offered me a replacement, return or keep it for a 20% refund.  Given that I had the other set, I went for the 20% refund.   I provided photos of the chip and it was all completely painless.  I would certainly continue to use Wayfair as the service is good.