This is a nice shelf for the price. The metal work is a little cheap looking and one of the welds was broken off when it arrived. I glued it back on as it is only for show and has no structural value. It arrived with a small dent on the metal tubing also. I felt it wasn't significant enough to return it. Repackaging this thing would be a major ordeal. Quite easy to put together and everything lined up fine. the price is the real plus here. A shelf this size could easily cost double what I paid  for it.